Inspirant Fact-check publié le

đŸ€” Une baleine prise au piĂšge remercie ses sauveurs

⚠ À nuancer

Le post

A female humpback whale had become trapped in about 20 crab-pot ropes, which are 240 feet long with weights every 60 feet. Rope was wrapped at least four times around the tail, the back and the left front flipper, and there was a line in the whale's mouth. A fisherman spotted her just east of the Farallon Islands, beyond the Golden Gate, and radioed for help. Within hours, a rescue team arrived. The assessment was grim. There was only one way to save her. They would have to get in the water. One strike of her tail could kill a diver. One sudden panic turn could end everything. But there was no other option. The team slipped into the cold Pacific, working for hours with curved knives. Line by line. Trap by trap. They stayed calm while she strained and twisted, while the ocean rolled beneath them. At one point, a rescuer cut the rope free from her mouth. He later said her eye followed him the entire time, watching. A level of awareness he would never forget. When the last line fell away, she was free. What happened next stunned everyone. Instead of disappearing into the deep, the whale swam in wide, flowing circles around the divers, as if testing her freedom, as if celebrating it. Then she did something no one expected. She returned. One by one, she approached each diver. She nudged them gently. Touched them. Pushed softly, deliberately, as though offering thanks. No panic. No aggression. Just presence. Several rescuers later said it was the most beautiful moment of their lives. The man who freed her mouth said he was changed forever. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ This is just one of many stories we share in the ‘Awe and Wonder’ chapter of Beyond Duality, an 8 week online course created by Kasper Benjamin Reimer BjĂžrkskov and myself where we help you move past business-as-usual and green-growth techno-utopian fixes to what we actually need to do if we are to create a genuinely sustainable future. Here is some feedback we have received from the first group who began the 8-week course in February: "The best masterclass that I have done." - Laurent Jost "... it’s everything you’ve always wanted to know to understand the world you live in—but no one ever tells you." - Irene Gil "It is much more than a course. Life-changing is not an overstatement.” - RechtsanwĂ€ltin Ina Petra PĂ€ĂŸler-Setzepfandt Our next Beyond Duality group begins on 22nd June, places are filling up fast. Details on how to sign up are in the comments.
Image du post LinkedIn vérifié

Le fact-check

đŸ€” Anthropomorphism and Misidentified Imagery The image commonly shared with this story is misleading: it shows a different whale, photographed off Australia’s Gold Coast in September 2005. This confusion has been debunked by Snopes in its review of the humpback rescue near the Farallon Islands in December 2005, mentioned in the post. https://cvc.li/auINy https://cvc.li/sgbJC Rescuers reported that, once freed, the whale swam off before returning to nudge one diver and approaching every single rescuer, seemingly making eye contact. At 4:04 you can see a picture of the entanglement. https://cvc.li/aOwHh However, such behaviour should not be over-interpreted. e.g. this fin movement being a “thumbs-up” : https://cvc.li/gnSxt https://cvc.li/wiAEf Scientists stress that we do not know whether whales experience emotions like gratitude, and caution against projecting human feelings onto them i.e. anthropomorphism. https://cvc.li/krWFP While rescuers sometimes describe other “thank-you displays” such as breaching, rolling, or circling the boat after release, they are more likely physiological responses such as releasing stress, clearing debris, or restoring circulation after entanglement. https://cvc.li/rQTUG https://cvc.li/RqFAu

Historique

5 étapes
22 juin 2026 ‱ 21:37

Post Reçu

23 juin 2026 ‱ 11:39

En traitement

23 juin 2026 ‱ 12:59

Fact-check terminé

23 juin 2026 ‱ 14:54

Fact-check relu

23 juin 2026 ‱ 18:08

Publication

đŸ€” Anthropomorphism and Misidentified Imagery The image commonly shared with this story is misleading: it shows a different whale, photographed off Australia’s Gold Coast in September 2005. This confusion has been debunked by Snopes in its review of the humpback rescue near the Farallon Islands in December 2005, mentioned in the post. https://cvc.li/auINy https://cvc.li/sgbJC Rescuers reported that, once freed, the whale swam off before returning to nudge one diver and approaching every single rescuer, seemingly making eye contact. At 4:04 you can see a picture of the entanglement. https://cvc.li/aOwHh However, such behaviour should not be over-interpreted. e.g. this fin movement being a “thumbs-up” : https://cvc.li/gnSxt https://cvc.li/wiAEf Scientists stress that we do not know whether whales experience emotions like gratitude, and caution against projecting human feelings onto them i.e. anthropomorphism. https://cvc.li/krWFP While rescuers sometimes describe other “thank-you displays” such as breaching, rolling, or circling the boat after release, they are more likely physiological responses such as releasing stress, clearing debris, or restoring circulation after entanglement. https://cvc.li/rQTUG https://cvc.li/RqFAu

Vous avez une question, une remarque ou une suggestion ? Contactez-nous, nous vous répondrons au plus vite !

Nous contacter
Posez votre question Ă  VeraVera